Delivery Available. Check Postcode
Choosing a Birthday Cake should be exciting. Yet here you are, scrolling through dozens of options, second guessing every click. Too plain? Too much? Will they actually like it? Picking the right cake comes down to a handful of straightforward questions. Answer them honestly, and you'll land on something that genuinely delights.
Before flavours or decorations enter the picture, think about the person. What would they love? Consider their personality. Are they classic and understated, or do they light up at anything bold and Instagram worthy? Someone who wears neutrals and orders the same coffee every morning probably wants a beautifully executed chocolate cake. Meanwhile, the friend who coordinates birthday themes three months in advance might feel underwhelmed by vanilla sponge, however good it tastes. Age matters too. A child's birthday is meant to be playful and colourful so something like the Rainbow Relish Cake or the Round KitKat Cake would land perfectly. An adult milestone, such as a 40th birthday cake or a 50th, often calls for something with a bit more refinement.
This sounds obvious, but it's where a lot of cake regret begins. Order too small and you're awkwardly slicing slivers. Order too large and you're eating birthday cake for breakfast for a week (though some might call that a win). For intimate gatherings a 6 inch cake is usually ideal. It serves six to eight comfortably, looks elegant on the table, and doesn't create the pressure of a towering centrepiece. Larger parties need larger cakes, but don't just default to the biggest option. Twenty guests don't need a cake for forty. Check serving guides, and when in doubt, round up slightly rather than doubling.
Now the fun part. Flavour is typically where personal preference wins out, so if you know their favourite, honour it. If you're buying for a crowd with mixed tastes, here's a quick guide.
is the crowd pleaser that rarely disappoints. Rich, familiar, universally loved. For something indulgent, the Black Forest Cake brings cherries and cream into the mix. If you want chocolate with a playful edge, the Cookie Dripping Cake delivers spectacle alongside substance.
gets underestimated. Done well, it's light, buttery, and a perfect canvas for fillings and toppings. The Pink Vanilla Cake and Blue Vanilla Cake prove that vanilla can hold its own visually, while the Ivory Enchantment Vanilla Cake brings something more refined.
sits somewhere between chocolate and vanilla - lightly cocoa flavoured with that signature cream cheese frosting. It photographs well and tastes distinctive without being divisive. The classic Red Velvet Cake does exactly what you'd expect, while the Red Velvet Crunch Cake adds texture. For something with cleaner lines, the Crown Cream Square Cake looks striking on a table.
has earned its place as a modern favourite. If they've ever scraped the last bit of spread from a jar or asked for extra biscuits on a flight, you know what to do. The Irresistible Lotus Biscoff Cheesecake is exactly what the name promises. For the adventurous and for those who want to try the newest flavours - consider bold, unexpected flavours. The Dubai Dream Kunafa Cake brings Middle Eastern inspired flavours that feel special, while the Decadent Tiramisu Cheesecake offers coffee soaked sophistication.
Some occasions call for a cake that stops the room. The swirl and ribbon cakes add elegance to moment such as these. They're consistently popular for women's birthdays, Mother's Day, and celebrations where the cake needs to look as special as the occasion feels. The Sweetheart Swirl Cake, Rosy Swirl Fantasy Cake, and Duchess Delight Cake all deliver on this. They taste as good as they look, which matters when something this pretty arrives at the table.
If someone needs a gluten free cake or an eggless cake, ask directly rather than assume. "Might be fine" isn't a phrase anyone wants attached to their birthday. Check options carefully. A good bakery such as Cakes & Bakes will have genuine alternatives that taste like cakes worth celebrating.
Some cakes are designed to taste exceptional. Others are designed to make people reach for their phones before anyone's even cut a slice. What matters is matching the moment. A personalised photo cake with a birthday pic on cake creates an immediate emotional response. Want something more personalised? Order a completely custom cake For adults, particularly milestone birthdays, elegance often wins. A 21st birthday cake is a celebration of entering adulthood that can lean towards the fun and vibrant. But 50th birthday cakes and 60th birthday cakes are safest with something more refined. Of course, there is always room to make your cake humorous, depending on how lighthearted the birthday boy or girl is.
Certain birthdays carry more weight. A 21st marks a threshold. A 40th often triggers reflection (and jokes). A 50th is half a century. A 60th, for many, is when gratitude for the depth of their life so far takes center stage. For these, the cake is part of how the day is remembered. Choose something that feels intentional. A flavour they genuinely love. A presentation that suits their style. Something that says you paid attention.
You know this person. You know whether they'd rather have something familiar done perfectly or something surprising that sparks conversation. You know if they care more about how it tastes or how it looks. Get the feeling right, and the specifics tend to fall into place.
Start with the guest count and serving style. A 6-inch cake typically serves 6–8 for a small gathering; for parties, use the bakery’s serving guide and round up slightly so you don’t run short.
Chocolate is usually the safest crowd-pleaser because it’s rich, familiar, and widely liked. If you want something lighter, a well-made vanilla cake is a versatile second-best option.
Match the milestone to the person’s style: refined flavours and clean designs often suit 40th/50th/60th birthdays, while bold themes and playful designs fit 18th/21st celebrations.
Yes—always confirm allergies and preferences (eggless, gluten-free, vegan) before ordering. It’s the easiest way to avoid last-minute issues and make sure everyone can enjoy the cake.